article

Examining Trumps Alleged Plan for Ukrainian Deportations

6 min read

Are Ukrainians being deported to a war zone? Yes — but the claim they’re being sent “to fight Putin” isn’t proven.

The Trump administration is preparing to deport some Ukrainians with final removal orders — roughly 80 people — and at least one man could be sent out as early as Monday. But a key detail got overhyped: there is no public list of 80 names, and it’s not confirmed these deportees will be forced to fight upon arrival.

Here’s what the records and officials actually show — and what they don’t.

The biggest correction up front

A plan built for a country at war — and closed skies

Ukraine’s airspace is shut to commercial flights. So U.S. deportations would likely route via another country, often Poland — exactly what detainees report ICE officers have told them.

The human stakes, in their own words

Andrey Bernik says ICE told him he’d be flown to Poland on a charter and handed to Ukrainian authorities. “I deserve to get deported, but not in the war zone,” he told the Washington Post. California records show he was found suitable for parole in June 2024; court summaries indicate his sentence was commuted in 2022. Source: washingtonpost.com.

Roman Surovtsev, 41, could be removed “as early as Monday,” according to a Justice Department filing. His lawyers fear detainees are being pushed out without a fair chance to claim protection — which they argue would be unlawful — and warn deportees may face wartime mobilization under martial law. Sources: washingtonpost.com.

An adviser to Ukraine’s president, speaking anonymously, put it bluntly: “The U.S. can deport as many as they want… We’ll find good use for them.” Source: washingtonpost.com.

What’s verified

What’s uncertain or needs more evidence

Lawyers argue it would be unlawful to remove people without a chance to raise “reasonable fear” claims — especially to a country under martial law. DHS says Surovtsev received due process and stresses that ICE doesn’t discuss future operations. That tension — between wartime realities and immigration procedure — is where the next legal fights will likely land. Sources: washingtonpost.com.

What changed with Ukraine’s cooperation?

Historically, Ukraine wasn’t fully cooperative in some U.S. deportation cases. Now, amid a full-scale war, Kyiv appears more willing to take nationals back — with transfers routed via third countries because of closed airspace. That’s a practical shift, not proof of any promised quid pro quo. Sources: washingtonpost.com, reuters.com.

Quick corrections to the original article

How we know what we know

Bottom line